To Subdue and Persecute

Pubmat by Marquee Ong

by Zachary Luis Arenal

When dissident voices are met with clenched fists, can these forces truly “serve and protect”?

Prompted by the 49th Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN) Summit, numerous demonstrations occurred across Metro Manila from November 15 to 17. The rallies comprised around 6,000 protesters, mostly in opposition to US President Donald Trump’s diplomatic visit and the proposed Pax Silica initiative, a 4,000-acre AI industrial hub in New Clark City, Tarlac. Throughout the three-day period, numerous clashes between police and protesters were reported all across the cities in the region. More than 300 were arrested by the Philippine National Police (PNP), with reported cases of violence. After calls from human rights organizations such as Amnesty for the release of the arrested demonstrators, 233 have been discharged, confirmed by the Department of Justice.

Yet, the populace is not blind to the blatant excesses of the PNP, as well as President Marcos Jr.’s administration. For years, those willing to speak out against the issues transpiring around the country have been met with deeply ingrained policies of excessive police force, dispersals, and red-tagging that aim to dissuade dissent. Injustices against the right to organize have occurred in every administration, and it is high time to end it.

To Serve

While maximum tolerance policies to mitigate clashes and casualties are being disregarded out on the street, the right to organize is upheld at a minimum. Outlined in the Public Assembly Act of 1985, “no person can be punished or held criminally liable for participating in or attending an otherwise peaceful assembly, even if the rally or gathering lacks a required written permit,” clearly stating that demonstrators must never be subjected to excessive physical violence under any as organizers are the ones responsible for handling and confronting legal repercussions. Despite any circumstances such as rallying without a permit or demonstrating outside public freedom parks, the rallyist must never be the one to face the brunt of the consequences. Even in Liwasang Bonifacio, a freedom park in Manila where a permit is not needed to organize, rallyists were still met with excessive police force and dispersals with eyewitness reports of an individual being beaten unconscious and two struck in the head with a riot shield. An administration meeting concerned voices with the threat of violence harkens back to President Marcos Jr’.s namesake, where brutality was commonplace even in rallies that were within legal bounds.

The current Commander-in-Chief wants to soften his image and assure us that the brutalities of his father, President Ferdinand Marcos, will not recur, yet it is all empty rhetoric if he is complacent with blatant human rights violations by forces under his thumb.

Incidents seen during the summit demonstrate a lack of discernment and discipline by police forces in upholding laws that protect the right to organize. Of the hundreds arrested, nine were detained in a freedom park, along with 22 journalists across Metro Manila, emblematic of the press persistently facing suppression and criminalization while in the line of duty. Many have decried the situation, in particular, the human rights non-governmental organization Karapatan, stating, “These disturbing scenes, recorded in full public view, expose the brutality of the police and the extent to which state forces are willing to go to suppress dissent. The PNP has turned a public space meant for the exercise of people’s democratic rights into a site of violence and repression.” The temperament and self-restraint of these forces must be trained to treat rallyists as concerned citizens exercising their right, rather than combatants ready to be inflicted with harm. 

What happened during the ASEAN summit isn’t an anomaly in the PNP’s track record, but an addition to their long history of violence against demonstrators. Incidents such as the 2004 Hacienda Luisita Massacre, 2016 Kidapawan Protests, and even the Flood Control Rallies of recent years all embolden the idea that there is a systemic preference of the agency for excessive force, dispersal, and violence. It is not a partisan issue where one can point to a single political camp as the problem, as every administration can be found guilty of letting it occur. It is an issue rooted in the heart of how police are trained and accustomed to treating demonstrators that is susceptible to change. Reforms such as limiting legal immunity, the use of body cameras, and enhanced de-escalation training have been proven to curb police brutality in other countries, and implementing these changes would provide a framework of handling demonstrators despite aggravation. If this administration truly is in the pursuit of a country with peaceful discourse, it must prioritize reforming the police force into a more accountable and composed police force.

To Protect

These demonstrations show the stark divide between the Filipino masses and the ruling class. Yet, the system of policing rallies would rather inflict harm on citizens in protection of leaders that exploit it. The nature of the rallies opposes individuals and institutions that oppress the country’s most marginalized — indigenous people, farmers, and workers — a clear indication that these movements are not meant to cause disorder or turmoil that necessitates being met with force. Their opposition to Pax Silica is a matter of their ways of life as it entails displacement from ancestral territories, conversion of agricultural lands, and insufficient wages in rural communities. If the response is to attack and silence them, it is not a far cry from dubbing the agency as apathetic to the concerns of the most vulnerable. The PNP’s guiding principle of “to serve and protect” only applies to the rich, powerful, and influential.

It is no longer limited to a “few bad cops,” but rather a system that has rotted to its core. The agency’s priorities and measures aim to disincentivize the act of protesting, as it is not politically fortuitous for any administration. However, it is not a right that can be curbed or limited because it is fundamental to how this country has its discourse of ideas, lest they risk the populace resorting to violent means just to make their voices heard. The right to organize is enshrined in almost every society because it is the most civil avenue for the masses to reach those in power; it must not be dismantled to preserve the interests of a few elites. While the PNP preserves these systems as it is politically beneficial to those in power, it will never fulfill its ideal of justice that serves the country’s least fortunate.

The demonstrations have been met with indifference by the administration, with Communications Undersecretary Claire Castro stating in a press conference that activists rally for almost every occasion, furthering her point by expressing “[t]ayo po yata ang bansang pinakamaraming nagra-rally.” Although the administration wants to belittle the existence of these rallies, they must be reminded that while their failings manifest in the lives of Filipinos and criticism is not met with understanding but with brutality, loud voices of opposition are expected. As long as there are administrations, institutions, and policies that vehemently make life harder for everyone, seeing large swaths of the population expressing their disapproval must not come as a shock.

If the Marcos administration and its PNP continue to tolerate these brazen acts of violence, then a motto of “to subdue and persecute” is more apt for the agency. 

Leave a Reply